April 21, 2010
John Kottcamp
Uncategorized
Closed Loop Marketing, Interactive Marketing, integrated marketing, Customer Experience, marketing technology, Customer Relationship Management, Metrics, digital agency, marketing2.0, agency2.0, web2.0, social networking, CMO, #Forrester, B2B marketing, Ascentium, Adage
Increasingly CMO’s are being brought into the technology buying process as technology is becoming even more intertwined with today’s multi-channel, multi-device world of marketing. And it’s up to us in the agency world who call ourselves trusted advisors to come to their aid.
It’s impossible to be a successful chief marketing officer (CMO) without becoming engaged in the understanding and decision making regarding technology. In a recent Forrester Research study, “The CMO’s Role in Technology Decisions”, David Cooperstein states that while “traditionally, marketing leaders treated IT as a foreign land that had a native language they didn’t speak… today’s marketers can’t afford to be lost in translation because digital channel embed technology in everything, marketing and the multi-channel customer experience are inextricably linked and fewer resources require strapped marketers to use technology to scale.” In other words, CMOs don’t really have a choice, either they need to learn the language of technology or they will not be able to compete in today’s digitalized, mobilized and socialized world of the interactive, integrated customer experience.
So who can help CMO’s learn the language of technology? Most (55%) look to their own IT departments , even though “strained” was the most common word to describe the typical relationship between CMOs and CIOs . And in smaller numbers, they look to their traditional agencies (21%) and management consultants (17%) for support. But almost half are looking towards their interactive agencies (49%) and their marketing services providers (44%) . And it is this audience that I believe has the responsibility to take the lead in helping CMOs navigate and make the smart business decisions that make the difference between leadership and falling behind.
But even within the worlds of the interactive agency or the marketing service providers, there are still large gaps in understanding what technology means for marketing and how to make the most of limited resources and the rapidly changing world of the customer experience. Most interactive agencies are either focused on online advertising or the increasing diversity of rich applications for platforms like Facebook or smartphones. While marketing service providers continue to concentrate on the silos of their own product’s capabilities despite the expansion of technology communities like Salesforce.com’s Appexchange or Omniture’s Genesis program.
At the risk of drawing the ire of my agency colleagues, I see the greatest opportunity in the hands of the emerging marketing practices of marketing consultancies like Accenture Interactive or McKinsey or the consulting arms of research organizations like Forrester or eMarketer. If CMOs have to be able to understand how technology will help them in the achievement of their business goals, then they need help from someone who first understands their business, their customers and how the complexity of the customer experience across all touch points can be influenced, optimized and in the end monetized.
And so it’s up to all of us in the agency world to embrace new roles as not just stewards of the brand, but as, business consultants who look equally to the worlds of creative, big ideas and technology as the best way to add values to our clients, the CMO. Because if we don’t step up to the challenge, someone else will.
1 Forrester Research, June 2009 Global Marketing Leadership Online Survey
2 Forrester Research, 2008 Partnering for Success: The CMO-CIO Relationship
3 Forrester Research, June 2009 Global Marketing Leadership Online Survey
April 7, 2010
John Kottcamp
Uncategorized
Closed Loop Marketing, integrated marketing, Customer Experience, marketing technology, Customer Relationship Management, Customer Lifecycle, digital agency, social media, agency2.0, web2.0, social networking, CMO, #Forrester, B2B marketing, Ascentium, Adage, Sean Corcoran, Dave Frankland, Vidya Drego
The other week, a new report came out of Forrester Research, entitled, The Future of Agency Relationships by three analysts, Sean Corcoran, Dave Frankland and Vidya Drego. First, I highly recommend reading the full report if you have Forrester access. You can also check out Sean’s blog post, Marketers Must Lead Agency Change or read Michael Bush’s article in AdAge, Memo to Marketers: It’s Your Fault if Your Shop Flounders.
All the coverage does a good job of summarizing the changes to the way agencies should provide value to their marketing clients and more importantly to their clients’ customers, be they consumer or businesses. Forrester has identified three fundamental services they feel agencies must provide: Ideas, Interaction and Intelligence. They call it adaptive marketing. And they are sending a clear message to marketers that the burden is in their court to demand these services of their agencies.
I agree with the logic. Ideas will always be central, but if and only if, the ideas can be developed and converted into real, meaningful and engaging experiences for customers. As Forrester say, “Experiences become more prominent than campaigns.” Interaction is the process of converting ideas into experiences. And in general the process for interaction is what is changing most radically. Interaction used to be the consumption of messaging, mostly through traditional channels like broadcast and print. But today with the explosion of channels, devices and emerging media, interaction is highly dependent on technology to bring the “big idea” to life. And this is one of those areas where it’s the agency that needs to change more than the marketer.
Agencies can no longer hide behind the big idea or the visually arresting creative treatment alone. If they cannot provide experiences that they, together with the marketer, and most likely the client’s IT department as well, can build, execute, support and track, they will not be successful in a highly digitalized world.
And this leads to Forrester’s third “I”, intelligence. Customer intelligence is, or should be, at the core of every action, experience and program agencies promote, marketers adopt and businesses demand. While much of the process of coming up with the “Big idea” is still a very right brain, creative exercise, which demands talent, experience and the ability to communicate, it is the question of who do you communicate with, how, when and with what message that is at the heart of customer intelligence, or left brain marketing. Any agency that does not understand and value the role of data, research and measurement will not be able to deliver success to their clients. And any marketer who does not demand measureable success from their agencies will not be able to translate those marketing metrics into the business metrics that drive a company’s “C-Suite” and that will reward marketers with budgets, respect and a seat at the business table, which is definitely where a CMO should sit.
So, go check out the Forrester report and think about how it should impact your business, whether you are a corporate marketer, an agency or a marketing services provider.
March 19, 2010
John Kottcamp
CMO, Customer Engagment, integrated marketing, Marketing, Marketing Strategy, Strategy
Adage, brand marketing, CMO, Customer Experience, digital agency, Forrester Research, integrated marketing, marketing2.0, Metrics, social networking, Starbucks, web2.0
I don’t ever like being critical of any of my peers, but sometimes, I just have to call a spade a spade. I just finished reading an article in Adage, entitled, “Our Biggest Brands can no longer be managed by nerds” by Tom Hinkes. His basic premise is that using data to inform marketing decisions somehow is responsible for the loss or the demise of CPG brands.
While I agree that “brand marketing is not a science, it requires analysis, discipline and detail. Even more, it requires intuition, flair and vision,” what I disagree with is the confusion between data and “numbers”. Using advances in market research, analytics and more recent social monitoring to listen to your customers, gain a greater understanding of what motivates them and responding to their needs/desires is not being a “bean counter”.
What made Starbucks a success was not that Howard Schultz ignored the research and went with his gut; it was that he was able to see the real needs/desires of his audience. They weren’t interested in coffee or soft drinks; they were interested in human interaction and a place where that could happen. And that type of insight is exactly what data and the successful understanding of data can bring about.
So I would counter that it’s some traditional brand managers who can’t see the forest for the trees and it takes a new more strategic business focused approach to be successful in today’s marketplace. So instead of being afraid of nerds, learn to listen and then apply the intuition, flair and vision that makes brand marketing as much art as science.
March 18, 2010
John Kottcamp
Uncategorized
agency2.0, Alaska Airlines, American Marketing Assocation, Ascentium, Brand, Customer Experience, Customer Relationship Management, Direct Marketing Association, integrated marketing, marketing2.0, MarketMix, rei, SDMA, social media, Tom Douglas, web2.0
Last week, I had the privilege of hosting Marketmix 2010, a marketing conference held in Seattle and co-sponsored by the Seattle Direct Marketing Association, of which I’m the current president and the Puget Sound chapter of the American Marketing Association. The theme was mixology, which was the creative expression of our idea of presenting content and topics bringing together the various marketing disciplines and channels covering online, offline and emerging channels like social and mobile.
The event itself was wildly successful. It was very close to a sold out crowd and most of the breakout session were standing room only. The three keynotes of the day were about as representative of Seattle as possible. The day kicked off with Steve Jarvis VP of Marketing at Alaska Airlines sharing the stage with Andrea Schwarzenbach who drives Alaska’s interactive efforts. And the day was rounded out with the closing keynote given by Tom Vogl, VP of Marketing for REI. Both keynotes showed how brands are grounded solidly in customer experience and that the ownership of those experiences goes far beyond the marketing department. The presentations were recorded and I’ll update this post as soon as they have been posted.
But it was the lunch keynote that surprisingly left me with the most to think about. The speaker was Tom Douglas, Seattle’s resident celebrity chef, owner of five successful restaurants, a line of kitchenware on Amazon, a dozen cookbooks and appearances just about everywhere. I had the chance to talk with Tom before his speech and he asked me why we had invited a chef to come speak to a bunch of marketers. I said something about his having built himself into a successful brand and was really thinking to myself that he served as a break from the more intense marketing subjects covered at the conference.
As soon as Tom began speaking, I realized that not only had we picked a good speaker, but that he also had something to teach all of us wizened marketing experts. “You have to live your brand,” Tom told the crowd. Every day you have to be true to your brand or it won’t have any credibility and it won’t last. He also was very proud to say that he linked himself very directly with the Seattle brand. He represents what makes us unique up here in the Pacific Northwest; from our salmon to our wine and of course our addiction to coffee. Tom finished his talk, taking lots of questions, getting wonderful applause and unabashedly telling us to go out and eat and his restaurants. After all, building a brand is just a way to grow the business.
The next day, I was walking down the street in downtown Bellevue, on the Eastside. For those of you who don’t know the geography, culture and snobbery of Seattle, Bellevue is a former bedroom community whose population, wealth and skyline has exploded in the last decade or so. Like so many prosperous suburbs, it residents are well educated, have higher than average incomes, are generally transplants from the suburbs of some other metropolitan area and tend to like the more fashionable brands. True Seattleites tend to look down on Bellevue and it wasn’t so many years ago, it was referred to as the Californication of the Northwest.
To be fair to Bellevue, which is where my office is and where I spend a lot of my waking hours, it has matured significantly over the years and while still run the risk of being run down by BMWs, Lexuses or the occasional Ferrari if you actually walk on the streets, it is no longer the cultural wasteland we Seattleites like to think it is.
But back to Tom Douglas and living you brand. As I was walking down the streets of Bellevue, I walked past an Italian restaurant, an Irish pub, a Mexican joint and several flavors of steak and seafood establishments. All are respectable and offer quite an assortment of cuisines. But then I realized what they all had in common; they were all parts of national chains.
I could think of at least a dozen neighborhoods in as many cities, where I could walk down a block and find the same set of choices. That was nothing that spoke with any authenticity to the Pacific Northwest, there wasn’t a real Mr. Maggiano, they don’t really manufacture cheesecakes and I doubt I will ever meet the real Joey. In fact the only place I could think of that really was real, was the Twisted Cork, located adjacent to the Bellevue Hyatt. (Irony of irony, since I wrote this post over the last couple of days, Twisted Cork has gone out of business)
So Tom, thanks for sharing with us your brand, thanks for living it and I hope that your authenticity will survive the onslaught of artificial brands that serve us plastic food, with plastic smiles and not so slowly turn our unique identities into a 21st century high-end strip mall.
March 3, 2010
John Kottcamp
Marketing, integrated marketing, Interactive Agency, Marketing Strategy, Ascentium
Closed Loop Marketing, Interactive Marketing, integrated marketing, Customer Experience, marketing technology, avenuea/razorfish, Customer Relationship Management, digital agency, microsoft, marketing2.0, agency2.0, web2.0, CMO, Ascentium, Razorfish, T-Mobile, Cisco, BSSP, Butler Shine Stern and Partners, Adweek, Precor, Samsonite, experience agency, chief client officer
I am proud to welcome the newest addition to Ascentium’s ranks, David Blum who has joined in the newly created role of chief client officer. David has joined Ascentium after leading interactive for Butler, Shine, Stern and Partners, the Bay area advertising agency, named small agency of the decade by Adweek.
Not only does David bring tremendous talent, energy and experience to the job, but what is more important is what it represents to an agency like Ascentium.
Over the last few years, Ascentium has been steadily building a reputation as one of the nation’s leading digital agencies, producing great work for client’s like Microsoft, T-Mobile, Cisco, Precor and Samsonite. But being the best digital agency is only a milestone on the road to helping redefine what agencies should look like in the future.
At our core, we are an experience agency. We meld passion for big ideas with an obsession for performance that produces engaging experiences, not just on the Web, but across multiple platforms, channels and devices. And to do that, we need to take from what traditional advertising agencies do best; own the “big idea” and manage account relationships and fuse that together with what digital agencies are known for; innovation leveraging emerging channels, technologies and customer behavior.
David Blum’s arrival at Ascentium will help us do that. His experience at BSSP helping to win major AOR accounts like Priceline, Allstate, Greyhound, Columbia Sportswear, Chipotle, Epson and Radio Shack coupled with the work he did managing Razorfish’s web development group in Seattle. Give testimony to Ascentium’s commitment to going beyond digital and leading the evolution into a true Experience agency.
Check out the article in today’s Adweek online about David, www.adweek.com.
February 25, 2010
John Kottcamp
Uncategorized
agency2.0, Ascentium, Customer Experience, digital agency, Groundswell, integrated marketing, social media, social networking, WebTrends
A couple of weeks ago, I had the privledge of speaking at Webtrends Engage 2010, their annual user conference. Each speaker was given 5 minutes to present a keynote. Here’s the link to the video http://tiny.cc/P2xgp
November 13, 2009
John Kottcamp
Ascentium, CMO, integrated marketing, Interactive Agency, Marketing, Marketing Strategy, SDMA, social media, social networking, Strategy
#Forrester, Adage, agency2.0, AKQA, Ascentium, CMO, Customer Experience, Customer Relationship Management, digital agency, integrated marketing, Interactive Marketing, Jacques-Herve Roubert, marketing technology, marketing2.0, Metrics, ROI, SDMA, social media, Tribal DDB, Twitter, web2.0
I read a very good and insightful article in today’s Adage, “Why Digital Agencies are Indeed Ready to Lead” by Jacques-Herve Roubert. I agree with his contention that Digital agencies are indeed ready to lead and as he points out, our company, Ascentium, is demonstrating that in fact with our relationship with Precor, but also increasingly so with some of our other accounts who are looking for to us for ideas and strategy and their traditional agencies for mass advertising.
The reasons for this are many and you pointed out some really good ones regarding where the energy, ideas and innovation is coming from. But the basic underlying reason is rooted in the business model of the big traditional agencies more than anything else. The traditional business model is based on revenue streams from media, not direct billable hours. This means that to be successful, agencies were forced into thinking about media as the prime distribution channel because that is how they make money. Digital agencies are not boxed in that way and as a result, they are able to look more broadly across channels and take a more customer-centric approach to communication than a media or product based approach.
Devotion to gathering customer intelligence across multiple channels online, offline and emerging social channels and then applying that to create customer experiences which produce trackable and measureable results is the key to our success at Ascentium and I believe that same can be said for the other great emerging digital agencies cired as well, like AKQA and TribalDDB. The big agencies are saddled with the innovator’s dilemma and while it won’t be the end of them, it certainly erects a big speed bump to innovation.
October 18, 2009
John Kottcamp
Uncategorized
Closed Loop Marketing, Interactive Marketing, integrated marketing, Customer Experience, marketing technology, Customer Relationship Management, Metrics, digital agency, social media, marketing2.0, web2.0, social networking, CMO, B2B marketing, SDMA, Ascentium, Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, Integrated Marketing Communicaitons Conference
My company, Ascentium, was named by Forrester Research, as one of the top web design agencies in the country last summer. It was an honor and I think a fair reflection of some great Web sites we’ve been building. But at the risk of diminishing the importance of Web site, I believe we’ve entered a new era, when producing a great web site is not enough to have an effective web presence and to keep up with your customer’s digital experiences.
The other week, I had the privilege of speaking at the first annual Integrated Marketing Communications conference in Kansas City. My topic was the introduction of the Integrated Digital Experience concept. Its premise is fairly simple and does not represent rocket science. But like most important concepts, its not the understanding that’s difficult, it’s the implementation that’s hard.
I’ve uploaded my slide deck to SlideShare and in future posts, will begin elaborating on what IDE means and what are some easy steps to making it happen. Check it out at http://www.slideshare.net/jkottcamp/the-digital-experience .
October 18, 2009
John Kottcamp
Uncategorized
Closed Loop Marketing, integrated marketing, Customer Experience, branded entertainment, marketing technology, Customer Relationship Management, Metrics, social media, marketing2.0, web2.0, social networking, B2B marketing, SDMA, Ascentium, Twitter, Privacy, Digital Hollywood, #DH09, Simulmedia, Dave Morgan, Michael Dougherty, Jelli, Shai Samet, Samet Privacy LLC, Jason Cieslak, Siegel & Gale, Mark J. Kapczynski, Kontrol Media, consumer privacy, tracking and targeting, consumer rights, commerce services
I’ve been given the privilege of speaking on a panel at next week’s Digital Hollywood in Los Angeles. The topic is Consumer Privacy, Tracking & Targeting: Consumer Rights and Enhanced Technology and Commerce Services. I’m being joined by a great group including Dan Palmer, VP, Atigeo, Bant Breen, President, Initiative, Dave Morgan, CEO, Simulmedia, Michael Dougherty, CEO, Jelli, Shai Samet, CEO, Samet Privacy LLC, Jason Cieslak, Managing Director, Siegel & Gale and moderated by Mark J. Kapczynski, Chief Operating Officer, Kontrol Media.
I will be tweeting from Digital Hollywood as well as posting after our panel discussion. It looks like it’s going to be a lively topic and I’m excited to be participating.
October 18, 2009
John Kottcamp
Uncategorized
#ForresterResearch, agency2.0, B2B marketing, CMO, Customer Experience, Customer Relationship Management, digital agency, Facebook, Groundswell, Integrated Digital Experience, integrated marketing, Integrated Marketing Communications, Interactive Marketing, LinkedIn, marketing2.0, Peter Burris, SDMA, social media, social networking, Twitter, web2.0
I had the opportunity to speak to the Forrester Research Technology Marketing Executive Council recently in conjunction with the Technology Forum in Chicago. The central theme of my talk was simply stated, as marketers, we need to start integrating social media into the rest of your marketing strategy and programs and stop treating Social Media as some magical new quasi religion.
I do not mean that there are not unique attributes of each of the various new channels, media and technologies that comprise social media; blogs, social networks like Facebook and LinkedIn, Twitter that we must examine, learn how to use and take advantage of in creating dynamic and meaningful experiences for consumers and businesses alike.
What I do mean is that instead of starting off with the attitude of “I’ve got to get me some of that Social Media stuff,” and invariably jumping right into figuring out which technology you need to buy, install and staff up to support, marketers needs to go back to their overall marketing strategies and figure out how each of the facets of social media can be leveraged to support their strategies, not drive them.
At this Forrester Research event, I had the privilege of delivering my talk on the heels of a presentation by Peter Burris, a research director at Forrester and a really smart and articulate guy. Peter’s theme was based on his recently released piece, Turning Your B2B Web Site Into A Community Hub. His premise, which I completely agree with, is that you need to start looking at how you integrate social media into your corporate Web presence. It is also related to the presentation I did at the Integrated Marketing Communications conference in Kansas City (see my post entitled, It’s time to look beyond Websites and start looking at an Integrated Digital Experience).
I won’t go through my entire presentation here, I’ve uploaded it at SlideShare and I encourage you to take a look. http://www.slideshare.net/jkottcamp/marketing-and-social-media-tmec-oct09
Older Entries
Newer Entries